I believe genuine Christians are of the "radical center" and will make a provisional alliance with either the left or the right, depending on specifics. Many of us identify with the political right in this time and place because that's where people with traditional faith convictions find the most hospitable home. But because our faith comes before ideology, we seldom fit neatly within the political divisions of the moment.

Frankly, Rod, beyond party politics, I don't think you’re a “conservative,” except in that provisional sense. Your Christian bleeding heart for those denied health insurance, for animals treated like widgets, for families subject to the tidal wave of media decadence, your concern about racism, about greed, etc. reflect a sensibility that is more concerned with justice, with "the least among us," than with order and social hierarchies. I’m not saying that you’re a liberal, but your tendency to side with the underdog, to question the “rules” is not historically what can be called “conservative” (unfortunately). I would say a liberal always wants to junk the rules when he sees exceptions. A conservative almost always wants to preserve them to maintain order. I would argue that a Christian, in imitation of Jesus, knows when and when not to break the rules (or how to paradoxically transcend them). That’s why we don’t ever fit neatly into political categories.

Oh, and Caleb, I don't think that deep down you're a conservative either. For similar reasons. You published Eugene McCarraher in the first issue of The New Pantagruel, after all, who certainly is not conservative.

Last, Alasdair McIntyre, the philosopher cited by Rod in his book, is of the "Radical Center" as well, and a good example of a politically homeless Christian. He advised people to sit out the last election. See his statement here.