
FROM THE ARCHIVES
[ home | archives | e-mail ]
Re: Religion
[Rod Dreher 03/22 01:01 PM]John Adams famously said: “We have no government armed with the power capable of contending with human passions unbridled by morality and religion. Avarice, ambition, revenge or gallantry would break the strongest cords of our Constitution as a whale goes through a net. Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.” Is cultural renewal in America possible absent a return to religious faith? (No; see John Adams.) Is conservatism possible today without religion, and the recognition of transcendentals entailed by religious belief? (Highly doubtful, if by conservatism we mean a political and cultural sensibility that wishes to preserve as distinct from petrify a living tradition shaped by particular moral convictions, and the institutions necessary to embody those abstract ideals.) Is religion possible in a meaningful sense in the Modern era without rootedness in a tradition that transcends time and place? (Maybe, but I have my doubts. The religious sentiment will always be with us; it’s built into the human character. But absent an authentic, authoritative tradition, how is it possible to keep religion from becoming merely the divinization of the Self’s desires? How do we keep God from looking a lot like ourselves in a time and place where individualism and self-expression are among the highest social values?)
Given the direction of American society, is it becoming harder or easier to be a good orthodox Christian or Jew and a good American? (In most ways, yes. The decline of public morality hardly needs commenting on. The deeper problem is that we have lost the vocabulary of moral absolutes, and increasingly, the only “thou shalt not” our pluralistic society recognizes is, “Thou shalt not impose your values on others.” This, of course, is only applicable to religious believers. A believer may keep his or her quaint devotions, but is expected to have the decency to keep them in the closet. And for many of us, the rot in the institutions that are supposed to be guarding the religious traditions leaves us feeling alone and abandoned. On the other hand, as Father Joseph Wilson says about Catholics, no Catholic who wants to know what their own Church teaches and believes needs to depend on priest and bishop; he can go straight to an online bookseller and buy whatever he likes, and he can easily find like-minded Catholics on the Internet. Technology, then, can serve to renew Tradition. But in my experience yours may differ, and I hope it does it is next to impossible to find any guidance in living an authentically religious life from one’s parish. Much religious life in America today seems to have accommodated itself quite nicely to the culture. Which makes it harder to live in an orthodox fashion. What are you supposed to do when the only doctrine ever heard from the pulpit is “I’m OK, You’re OK,” and you cannot be certain what anybody else in your church believes, other than the near-certainty that they believe they have the sovereign right to decide for themselves that they are their own Pope?)
|